The age-old question still stands: Does pineapple belong on pizza? Our answer is yes… but only when you’re eating pizza in a beachy destination like NSB! Though beloved for its seafood dining, New Smyrna Beach has a varied assortment of restaurants including fantastic pizzerias. From mom-and-pop pizza parlors to trendy, sit-down spots, our beach town has plenty of places where you can order a pie. Want dinner with a view? Book a NSB vacation rental and order take out/delivery from any of the below pizza spots for an ideal evening in.
Flagler Avenue Pizza Company
396 Flagler Ave, New Smyrna Beach, FL 32169 | Dine-in, takeout, and delivery.
As the name states, you’ll find this pizza joint right on the bustling Flagler Avenue. After playing in the surf all morning, stroll up the avenue for a New York style lunch. Flagler Avenue Pizza Company prides itself on authentic NYC pizzas each with a creative twist. From Chicken Vodka to Arugula and Prosciutto, you’ll find a wide variety of toppings and flavors on their menu. Already hungry? View their menu here.
113 S Orange St, New Smyrna Beach, FL 32168 | Dine-in, takeout, and delivery.
This family-owned business is a tasty one to support especially when they’re known for cheese breadsticks! Panheads Pizzeria is nestled amongst New Smyrna’s local hub, Canal Street. Though the dining ambiance is casual, you’ll find it a great dinner spot as they have a selection of red and white wine to pair with your pizza. For those who prefer a warm Italian meal, the restaurant serves dishes like Gnocchi Bolognese and Chicken Alfredo all served with homemade focaccia bread. View their menu and plan your visit.
3318 S Atlantic Ave, New Smyrna Beach, FL 32169 | Dine-in and takeout.
Though not flashy or trendy, this pizza spot has been a New Smyrna Beach staple for well over thirty years. With a pool table, arcade games, and casual seating, this restaurant is filled with 90’s nostalgia which makes it so endearing. Along with a walk down memory lane, Manny’s Pizza has a full menu of Italian dishes ranging from baked ziti to pizza. Ordering their Greek salad is a must- it’s nearly as popular as the pizza! See Manny’s Pizza’s menu here.
112 Sams Ave, New Smyrna Beach, FL 32168 | Dine-in and takeout.
Make pizza feel fancy and treat yourself to an upscale experience at Prima. This pizzeria is located in the historic downtown New Smyrna Beach and makes for a great date night. Start the evening with an appetizer of bruschetta fresca, antipasto and a glass of wine from their curated collection. From pesto-based pizzas to classic red sauce and cheese, you’ll find whatever you’re craving served on their menu. See their selection here.
Baci Pizza Restaurant
830 N Dixie Fwy, New Smyrna Beach, FL 32168 | Dine-in and takeout.
While takeout is available, don’t pass up the opportunity for an evening out as Baci offers a cozy Italian dining experience. With bottles of wine on display and a brick fire pizza oven, this restaurant is truly a local gem. If you’re still craving pizza after looking over their full Italian menu, you can’t go wrong with their wood fired eggplant pesto pizza. Gluten free options are also available. See their menu here.
From romantic Italian pizzerias to classic American pizza joints, New Smyrna Beach has a wide variety of places where you can pick up a pie. Stick around long enough to try them all when you spend a long vacation in New Smyrna Beach. We recommend ordering a few to your vacation rental and enjoying pizza on a scenic oceanfront balcony. View our vacation condos and homes online and book your NSB stay today!